The Buffalo Trace Wheated Bourbon Showdown: An Analysis of Buffalo Trace Kosher Wheat Recipe vs. Weller Special Reserve

As a seasoned aficionado of the Buffalo Trace W. L. Weller Collection, I have been drawn to the Buffalo Trace Kosher line, specifically its Wheat Recipe variant, and to its comparison with Weller Special Reserve. This examination of the "Buffalo Trace Wheaters" offers discerning connoisseurs an opportunity to delve deeply into the nuances of these esteemed wheated bourbons.

The Buffalo Trace Kosher Wheat Recipe represents a refined addition to the distillery's prestigious collection. Sharing a mash bill of 70% corn, 16% wheat, and 14% malted barley with the Weller Special Reserve, it matures over seven years and is bottled at an elegant 94 proof. Priced attractively between $45 and $55, it affords a high-quality alternative for those seeking the excellence of Weller bourbons at a more accessible cost.

Across various states, disparities in Weller product pricing are evident. In regions like New York and New Jersey, these products fetch a premium. Imagine paying up to $90 for a Weller Special Reserve, which is a significant hike from the recommended $30 to $35 at the distillery or in states with pricing regulations. This stark contrast means that for those of us in areas with inflated costs, the Buffalo Trace Kosher Wheat Recipe emerges as a promising alternative to the pricey Weller Special Reserve.

While some may regard the Buffalo Trace Kosher series as a mere offshoot of the Weller range, the Wheat Recipe distinguishes itself with an intricate flavor profile that rivals pricier offerings. This product presents notes of apple, cherry, cream, and caramel, accompanied by a syrupy texture.   Despite similar proof levels, the sophisticated attributes of these bourbons captivate enthusiasts.

The Kosher certification notably influences the sensory attributes and market positioning of the Wheat Recipe. Adhering to stringent kosher guidelines, it utilizes kosher-certified oak barrels and meticulous procedures to ensure compliance. This reflects Buffalo Trace’s commitment to diversity and offers insights into Jewish dietary customs.

Kosher food preparation demands rigorous separation of meat and dairy products, with most other foods being pareve (neutral). The regulations governing kosher preparation and cleanliness are exacting. Buffalo Trace's kosher whiskeys are aged in oak barrels certified by the Chicago Rabbinical Council, and bottling pipes are thoroughly cleaned to prevent cross-contamination.  Although specific details regarding the fermenting and distilling apparatus remain unspecified, these components are likely subject to rigorous standards to uphold kosher integrity.

In the realm of kosher whiskey, it might be compared to a refined "sweet mash" whiskey. This process involves crafting a fresh mash for each batch, in contrast to the "sour mash" method, which uses a portion from the preceding mash to facilitate and stabilize fermentation. It is unclear if this Buffalo Trace Bourbon uses a sweet or sour mash process.

It is crucial to recognize that the distinction between sour and sweet mash processes is founded on taste rather than religious practices. Observing kosher dietary laws (kashrut) enables Jewish individuals to honor their heritage and values, celebrating both physical and spiritual well-being. Historically, it serves as a homage to Jewish martyrs who chose martyrdom over violating their cherished dietary laws. This cultural appreciation transcends the seemingly simple acts of eating or drinking, becoming an expression of profound gratitude.

Let’s start our tasting analysis of Buffalo Trace Kosher Wheat Recipe vs. Weller Special Reserve. Adhering to the rigorous standards of Bourbon Awareness whiskey evaluations, this whiskey was tasted in a Glencairn glass, where it was allowed to rest for at least 10 minutes. The tasting was conducted with precision over two to three weeks, ensuring a comprehensive analysis of its intricate flavors and nuances.

Tasting Analysis of Buffalo Trace Kosher Wheat Recipe.

Appearance: Amber and golden caramel with medium-to-long legs.

PROOF – 94 proof        AGE – 7 years     Average Price - $45 to $55

Nose: The fragrance presents a blend of cherry reduction, roasted apple, and a hint of rich oak. Notes of Cinnabon’s, lemon peel, golden caramel, and ripe fruits enrich the aroma. Hints of vanilla pods, cloves, and wheat bread add complexity, showcasing distinguished oaken nuances.

Palate: Cherry and oak dominate, with a gentle vanilla-caramel note weaving through, accented by oak tannins. A syrupy texture and a medium viscous mouthfeel underscore everything. The aroma transitions seamlessly to the palate, presenting caramel, peaches, cherries, orange peel, vanilla, cloves, and again some oak. A hint of baking spice emerges, pleasantly coating the palate. This delightful, fruit-forward sipper is remarkably flavorful for its 94 proof.

Finish: The finish unfolds with a whisper of peppery essence, with the sweet, distinct oak tannins remaining most prominent. Subtle layers of baking spice like cinnamon, nutmeg, and a touch of cloves, complemented by caramel, stone fruits, and berries, create a lingering complexity. As the sip concludes, the oak evolves into refined leather tannins, culminating in a polished, medium-long finish.

Tasting Analysis of Weller Special Reserve.

Appearance: Medium Copper

Nose: The nose resonates with layers of caramel, vanilla, cherry, baked apple, oak, and honey, subtly infused with floral notes and a hint of cinnamon. There are hints of sugared cereal and wheat bread, culminating in soft, inviting waves of vanilla buttercream and cinnamon sugar effortlessly drifting from the glass.

Palate: On the palate, I get an initial impression of sophisticated notes of vanilla, caramel, and cinnamon, which establish a warm, smooth foundation. The pronounced fruit flavors manifest with grace, as apples and cherries are expertly enveloped in caramel. As the tasting experience progresses, cinnamon sugar mingles with apple and cherry flavors, alongside a subtle infusion of vanilla cream, offering a balanced mouthfeel that neither dilutes nor overpowers. The oak character, more pronounced than initially apparent, is integrated, enhancing the refined nature of this 90-proof offering. It strikes an impeccable balance, not too thin or dominant, with a satisfying complexity. The overall profile is balanced, with vanilla- and floral-honey sweetness, accentuated by hints of cherry, apple, peppercorn, and oak, creating a sophisticated tasting experience.

Finish: The finish is relatively short, bringing out subtle orange notes with a soft touch of vanilla and light pepper. These flavors emerge softly, never overpowering the main act, which is the subtle oak that lingers with an easygoing charm. As you finish, there's an unexpected edge of bitterness, woven with whispers of cinnamon, apple, black pepper, and a drizzle of honey. Meanwhile, you'll catch nuances of pepper, oak, and leather, leaving a slight bitterness that lingers after a hearty Kentucky chew. The experience hangs around with a fun mix of cinnamon, peppercorn, and honey dancing on your tongue.

Summary & Final Thoughts: The Kosher Wheat Recipe showcases a golden caramel hue and offers an inviting aroma of sweet caramel, peaches, baked apples, and subtle baking spices. On the palate, it delivers flavors of caramel, berries, and orange peel, with a hint of cloves and oak, and finishes long and satisfyingly. The Kosher Wheat Recipe shares similarities with Weller Special Reserve but features sweeter, lighter notes with hints of cinnamon and oak.

The Weller Special Reserve showcases a rich tapestry of caramel, vanilla, and cherry, complemented by baked apple, oak, honey, floral hints, and cinnamon. The palate reveals a sophisticated blend of vanilla, caramel, apple, and cherry, layered with cinnamon sugar and vanilla cream for a balanced, smooth taste. The oak character adds depth without overpowering. The finish brings out soft notes of orange, vanilla, and a hint of pepper, with subtle oak and a touch of bitterness, creating a refined and engaging tasting journey.

The decision not to label the Kosher Wheat Recipe as "Kosher Weller" is strategic, as it would inevitably command a premium price. Although there are differences in branding and packaging, the tasting experience closely resembles that of a Weller product. Yet, the Kosher certification signifies a notable distinction, albeit its flavor impact may be subtle to some palates.

My intrigue extends beyond the tasting spectrum to explore the kosher dimension. Although not of Jewish faith, my connection through marriage has provided insights into kosher practices. The guidelines require strict separation of meat and dairy products. For Buffalo Trace’s kosher whiskeys, barrels certified by the Chicago Rabbinical Council are utilized, and bottling equipment is rigorously cleansed to ensure purity.

While kosher whiskey may parallel "sweet mash" whiskey, adherence to Jewish dietary laws (kashrut) signifies a celebration transcending physical health to embrace spiritual and cultural nourishment. Released annually around Passover, yet not kosher for the holiday, this product astutely stimulates cultural curiosity.

After conducting a tasting evaluation, it is evident that Weller Special Reserve is appropriately priced at $30.00. Weller Special Reserve is a solid bourbon, but certainly not one to overpay for. The inflated market rates of $75 to $90 do not represent its actual value. Additionally, its proof is slightly lower by 4 degrees compared to the Kosher Wheat Recipe. From a value perspective, investing a little more in the vibrant and richer 94-proof Kosher Wheat Recipe at a reasonable $45.00 seems prudent. The Buffalo Trace Kosher Wheat Recipe stands out as an exceptional substitute for Weller Special Reserve.

In conclusion, the Buffalo Trace Kosher Wheat Recipe stands as a testament to America's Bourbon heritage, delivering an extraordinary tasting experience and inviting exploration of diverse cultural landscapes. Embracing the opportunity to learn about cultures beyond my own remains a priority, and this bourbon offers a rich, balanced experience steeped in cultural significance.

At Bourbon Awareness, you can learn more about America's native spirit. Bourbon Awareness and Whiskey University's sole mission is to educate the public about the history and virtues of Bourbon, Tennessee Whiskey, and other various whiskeys.

See our website at bourbonaware.com and whiskeyuniv.com/nj-central-new-jersey-area. You can contact us at harrycasazza@bourbonaware.com